The Old Town canoe with serial number 9858 is 16 long so my guess is that you have a Carleton canoe. The Carleton canoe with serial number 9858 is a 17 foot long, CS grade, Carleton model with western red cedar planking, open spruce gunwales, ash decks, ash trim, aand a keel. It was built between October, 1913 and June, 1914. The original exterior paint color was dark red. It shipped on June 29th(?), 1914 to Burt, New Mexico(?). A scan of this build record can be found by following the link under the thumbnail image attached below.