Your dedication to preserving your canoe including its decal is commendable, but just to present another alternative... Old Towns, including CS-grade Otcas, are not rare among wooden canoes (perhaps half of Old TOwn's production was CS grade, and perhaps 15% of the hundreds of thousands of their wooden canoes were Otcas). Given that the store decals are pretty good replicas of the originals, why not just go ahead and replace the whole thing? Surely the resulting decal will be at least as close to original as one pieced together from old and new (and still missing quite a few bits). You're done now and it looks fine, so I wouldn't change it necessarily at this point. What you've done illistrates your commitment to this canoe, and that's a good thing. This is just an alternative suggestion in case you choose to restore another canoe, or need to do further work on this one someday in the future.